2026-11-19 HUD Letter - Final Determination of Substantial Default

 

 

 

Leonard Spicer

Executive Director
Newark Housing Authority
500 Broad St
Newark, NJ 07102
Brian K. Logan
Chair, Board of Commissioners
Newark Housing Authority
500 Broad St
Newark, NJ 07102
FINAL DETERMINATION OF SUBSTANTIAL DEFAULT AND ELECTION OF
REMEDIES UNDER 42 U.S.C. § 1437(i)(3)(A)
Dear Mr. Spicer and Mr. Logan:

On September 22, 2026, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD")
issued a Determination of Substantial Default declaring the Newark Housing Authority ("NHA")
to be in substantial default for breaching the terms of the Recovery Agreement ("the
Agreement") it entered into with HUD on September 20, 2024. Specifically, NHA failed to
attain specific occupancy targets required under the plain terms of the Agreement. On November
5, HUD issued a supplemental letter notifying NHA of two additional grounds for substantial
default: failure to improve financial performance and failure to comply with financial
information submission requirements (collectively "Determination Letters").
Pursuant to 24 C.F.R. § 907.5(a)(3), NHA was given ten (10) calendar days from the date of each
to dispute the determination in writing and demonstrate to HUD that the determination of
substantial default was in error. NHA's written responses on October 2 and November 13
acknowledged its failure to achieve the occupancy and financial performance requirements
established in the Agreement but argued the metrics improved given the circumstances and
argued that the timing of the default determination was premature.
HUD has reviewed NHA's responses to the Determination Letters and found no basis to reverse
its previous determinations. NHA conceded that it has not complied with the Agreement's
occupancy and financial requirements. Moreover, NHA's rationalizations for its noncompliance
do not disturb this finding.
NHA has not taken good faith efforts to substantially improve. HUD regulations define
"substantial improvement" in quantitative, not qualitative, terms. See 24 C.F.R. § 902.75(d) and
(g). NHA needed to "improve its performance by at least 50 percent of the difference between
the initial PHAS assessment score that led to the troubled performer status and the score
necessary to remove the ... designation as a troubled performer" twelve months after receiving

the troubled performer designation and then increase that score by at least 60% of the total
available points 24 months after that designation. Id. NHA did not meet either benchmark-
both of which are mandatory-overall or on individual PHAS metrics. And, crucially, NHA
failed to meet those benchmarks even if HUD credited NHA additional points for its late FY
2024 financial filings.
HUD considered NHA's reported progress and claimed corrective efforts before determining
whether further action is warranted. Those efforts do not outweigh the continued failure to meet
benchmarks that NHA itself agreed to over two years ago. NHA is in substantial default under
the Agreement for the reasons described above and in the Determination Letters.
By this letter, HUD takes possession of NHA pursuant to Section 6(j) of the United States
Housing Act of 1937. Upon a declaration of substantial default due to breach of the Agreement,
HUD has broad discretion to take any action provided for in 42 USC § 1437d(j)(3)(A), including
by taking "possession of all or part of the public housing agency, including all or part of any
project or program of the agency[,]" and "requiring the agency to make other arrangements
acceptable to the Secretary." See 42. USC § 1437d(j)(3)(A)(iv) and (v). Therefore, the NHA
Board of Commissioners and its individual members are hereby removed and relieved of their
duties as commissioners, effective immediately.
Nothing in the Determination Letter or the remedial actions being taken by HUD shall be
understood to have waived HUD's right to exercise any other right or remedy permitted by
statute, regulation, and the Annual Contributions Contract, including but not limited to those
permitted under 42 U.S.C. § 1437d(j)(3)(A).
Should you have any questions regarding these timelines or requirements, please contact Howard
Cumme at Howard.S.Cumme@hud.gov.
Sincerely,

Benjamin Hobbs
Assistant Secretary
Office of Public and Indian Housing

Enclosures:
Attachment A - Determination of Substantial Default
Attachment B - NHA Response to Determination of Substantial Default on October 2, 2026
Attachment C-HUD response to Newark Housing Authority's Arguments Disputing the
Determination of Substantial Default & Additional Grounds for Substantial Default
Attachment D - NHA Response to Determination of Substantial Default on November 13, 2026

CC:

Towanda S. Macon
Director, Office of Prevention, Recovery, and
Transformation
Office of Public and Indian Housing

The Honorable Ras J. Baraka
Mayor of the City of Newark
Newark City Hall
920 Broad Street
Newark, NJ 07102

Brian K. Logan
Chair, Board of Commissioners
Newark Housing Authority
500 Broad St
Newark, NJ 07102

Imam Daud-Haqq
Vice Chair, Board of Commissioners
Newark Housing Authority
500 Broad St
Newark, NJ 07102

Vivian Cater
Chair, Board of Commissioners
Newark Housing Authority
500 Broad St
Newark, NJ 07102

Patrick Council
Chair, Board of Commissioners
Newark Housing Authority
500 Broad St
Newark, NJ 07102

Ashraf Latif
Chair, Board of Commissioners
Newark Housing Authority
500 Broad St
Newark, NJ 07102

Linda Washington
Chair, Board of Commissioners
Newark Housing Authority
500 Broad St
Newark, NJ 07102

 

Print
Categories: Uncategorized, Notices
Tags: